Bobby Flay is 3-9 against Indian. This is one of those nine, and the dish on the plate was potato latkes.
The episode listing reads Indian, and the dish reads latkes, which is the kind of cross-wiring that only happens on a Beat Bobby Flay episode where someone has decided to take a Jewish standard and refract it through Hudson Valley produce and Indian aromatics. Ric Orlando ran New World Home Cooking until 2018; he now teaches and consults and does pop-ups across the Hudson Valley.
Whatever it was, the judges chose it. The latkes ate Bobby's plate.