S22E1A Proper Smackdown

Aired 2019-08-29 · Bobby lost
Guests Valerie Bertinelli · Clinton Kelly
Round 1
Challenger W
Ian Winslade
vs.
Challenger L
Geoff Rhyne
Round 1 winner: Ian Winslade — advanced to face Bobby.
Round 2 · Bobby lost
Ian Winslade beat Bobby with Fisherman's Pie.

Winslade piped the potato topping to create ridged peaks with more surface area for browning and a stiffer mash ratio that held structure during baking. Pre-cooked smoked fish released no additional moisture into the filling during baking. Bobby's topping, judges noted, lost its peak definition.

Full defeat page →