S37E2Holiday Throwdown: Pie in the Sky

Aired 2024-11-19 · Bobby won

Guests Ina Garten

Round 1

Challenger W

Amanda Freitag

vs.

Challenger L

Aarti Sequeira

Round 1 winner: Amanda Freitag — advanced to face Bobby.

Round 2 · Bobby won

Bobby cooked shepherd's pie, and pumpkin pie. The judges chose him.

One of 329 wins. Amanda Freitag returned to their kitchen.