S39E2First Impressions

Aired 2025-05-01 · Bobby lost
Guests Alex Guarnaschelli · James Austin Johnson
Round 1
Challenger W
Stephanie Cmar
vs.
Challenger L
David Standridge
Round 1 winner: Stephanie Cmar — advanced to face Bobby.
Round 2 · Bobby lost
Stephanie Cmar beat Bobby with Lobster roll.

Cmar's steam method used the shell as a moisture barrier, producing drier meat than water-poaching. Chilling to 40°F before dressing prevented mayo breakdown from residual heat. Celery salt and white pepper only — no lemon juice — kept the emulsion stable from bowl to plate. Bobby's dressing broke slightly under the heat of the roll.

Full defeat page →